10 desembre 2010
Women influenced by the patriarchal society
In Elizabethan times, women were expected to behave as puppets dominated by men and understimated by a society which shouldn’t give them any type of right or freedom. They must remain virtuous until marriage and this fact leads to their weakness and vulnerability.
After reading some of the Shakespeare’s plays, we could see different cases such as Ophelia in Hamlet, one of the most typical characters who fits with the stereotype of women of that time. As it was common in Elizabethan times, Ophelia was a victim of submission and she has a dilemma between what she really feels and what she is told to feel. She loves Hamlet but in that society women had no voice and she must renounce to her own happiness and desires in order to obey his father’s ambitions. She expresses her love for Hamlet in front of the figure of her father:
My lord, he hath importuned me with love
In honorable fashion
‘And hath given countenance to his speech, my lord,
With almost all the holy vows of heaven.
(I.iii.109-13)
Ophelia is seen as the innocent, humble and inexperienced young girl that only loves Hamlet not for what he is in himself, but for that which appears to her: the gentle, brave and handsome prince. Her feelings are not relavant for anyone and this situation causes her to meet with two different situations: either disobeying her father’s desires or facing a Hamlet’s madness. The values and morals her brother and father force upon Ophelia are her first guided steps toward madness. Ophelia is trapped between youth and maturity because the power of men makes her feel as a child. She is considered as innocent, defenseless and helpless due to her dominating father and brother.
Another example is Hero from Much Ado about Nothing. She represents the typical figure of Elizabethan societies due to the fact that she is innocent, chaste and obedient: the perfect woman in a patriarchal society. Hero’s silence in the play at Claudio’s declaration of love shows a lack of confidence, she is not allowed to raise her voice and this is one of the factors in which Shakespeare criticises the feminine conventionality and the weakness of the women ideal in Elizabethan culture. At any moment, Hero accepts the decision of men as her own obligation and while her father and uncle are discussing about her future, she says nothing. At the end of the play, we could see how Claudio rejects her for being unfaithful and disloyal at their wedding ceremony:
O Hero! What a Hero hadst thou been
If half thy outward graces had been placed
About thy thoughts and counsels of thy heart!
But fare thee well, most foul, most fair, farewell
Thou pure impiety and impious purity.
For thee I’ll lock up all the gates of love,
And on my eyelids shall conjecture hang
To turn all beauty into thoughts of harm,
And never shall it more be gracious.
(IV.i.98–106)
Hero represents a character who is satisfied with her own situation; she accepts the male domination and willing to submit to men.
Introduction
Throughout this paper the topic of the role of women in the 16th century, and especially in Shakespeare’s plays, is commented in detail. Having read many Shakespeare’s novels, it is so difficult to discuss whether he was misogynist or feminist because of his broad portrayal about women’s roles in the different plays.
In the following sections, we could see how Shakespeare gives a particular role and function to every woman character, depending on her importance in the course of the action and her symbolism within the story. This paper is dealing with women such as Ophelia from Hamlet, Hero from Much Ado About Nothing, Cordelia from King Lear, Hermia from A Midsummer Night’s Dream and Katherina from The Taming of the Shrew. Finally, it is commented the relationship between different pairs composed of a man and a woman which have a complicated treatment or that could cause problems in the rest of the characters or in the development of the play.
7 novembre 2010
First Paper Bibliography (Political Discourse)
*Analyses based on the characters:
http://www.cdrnet.net/kb/data/en_golding.asp Web. 27/10/2010
* Main themes in Lord of the Flies (political system, leaderdhip and civilization vs.savagery):
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/862391/piggys_significance_in_lord_of_the.html?cat=38 Web. 27/10/2010
http://www.pinkmonkey.com/booknotes/monkeynotes/pmLordFlies30.asp Web. 28/10/2010
http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/flies/context.html Web.28/10/2010
http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/469378/the_symbolism_of_a_conch_shell_in_lord.html?cat=38 Web. 28/10/2010
http://www.megaessays.com/viewpaper/85745.html Web. 27/10/2010
First Paper Bibliography (Shakespeare)
* Feminism in Shakespearean plays:
http://internetshakespeare.uvic.ca/Library/SLT/society/duties.html Web. 7/11/2010
http://www.shomler.com/dance/dream/msdt.htm Web 2/12/2010
http://customessays.ws/blog/essay-on-female-characters-in-shakespeare-s-plays.html Web. 28/10/2010
http://absoluteshakespeare.com/plays/a_midsummer_nights_dream/a_midsummer_nights_dream.htm Web. 7/11/2010
http://www.uafortsmith.edu/Applause/FeminismInA PatriarchalSociety Web. 27/10/2010
http://www.wsu.edu/~delahoyd/shakespeare/sample5.html Web. 27/10/2010
* Shakespeare, William. A Midsummer’s Night Dream. Electronic ed.
<http://shakespeare.mit.edu/midsummer/full.html> Web. 28/10/2010
28 octubre 2010
Conclusion
There is no doubt that in Lord of the Flies we could see the dramatic results that would be in our society, in the civilization if the political system fails and also the terrible impact that would cause that failure in our country.
Unfortunately, anarchy defeats order and the situation becomes destabilized due to the fact that without rules and without any powerful person or weapon to govern, a war could maybe be the solution of this chaotic environment. The main problem according to William Golding is that tha lack of conficence in the governor of a system, makes him return to his roots and his own savageness.
Reflection in Politics
As a need for democracy and order to establish a society with the correct values, the political references are all around the book as a criticism in which is opposed totalitarism and liberal democracy. As a symbol of liberal democracy, we have the object of the conch, which restores the order over the group of children. In addition, the moment in qhich the conch is broken, everything is a chaos and nobody has control over a person: anarchy. The conch symbolises the right to speak, the same rights for all and the right of life and intactness, but only if the powerful people on the island (Jack) believe in such values. http://www.cdrnet.net/kb/data/en_golding.asp
As a good leader, you have also to confront to the society that refuses your proposals and discriminates him/her in order to being as cruel as possible. The insults and offences towards an inferior individual makes the rest of the people hates him/her and it gives power and security to the chief. This is the case of Piggy in the novel. Piggy’s character plays a major role because he serves as Golding’s personification of intelligent, rational thinking civilization; therefore, he is given internal and external characteristics that make him a figure of pacifist authority. http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/862391/piggys_significance_in_lord_of_the.html?cat=38
William Golding makes the reader see the relation that exists between that conch shell and the fact of being a president in a government. As in the real world, the possession of the power is the most valuable factor and in order to achieve that power, you must show to the country (the island) that you are more superior than the rest of individuals. Ralph is elected by the boys to be their chief. Governed by rationality, he tries to be a democratic leader, listening to the concerns of all (even the fears of the littleuns), watching out for the good of all (building and maintaining the fire), and protecting them all (building shelters). http://www.pinkmonkey.com/booknotes/monkeynotes/pmLordFlies30.asp
As the island civilization (the country) erodes and the boys (the population) turn into savages, the conch sell (the government) loses its power and influence over them. Everything is symbolical here and William Golding is criticizing that vision of humanity that he experiences in the World War II. In portraying the various ways in which the boys on the island adapt to their new surroundings and react to their new freedom, Golding explores the broad spectrum of ways in which humans respond to stress, change, and tension. http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/flies/context.html
He believed that the horrors of World War II can be based on some innate evil which he explores in Lord of the Flies. http://www.cdrnet.net/kb/data/en_golding.asp
Leadership
The importance of having a leader who dominates the situation and also the children is necessary from the first moment. The main idea of the novel is that the characters are children and due to their fear of the unknown real world, they need the presence of an adult. Therefore, they establish who is going to be their own leader in order to feel protected in front of any difficult situation. According to William Golding, Leadership plays a very important role in the novel as it does in real life for us, because the characters need to feel some sense of security in order for them to survive. http://www.bookrags.com/essay-2005/12/13/185154/04
Golding is criticising here the idea that those children have lost even their dreams, they stopped being children and innocent to start being violent. There is a point in the novel in which they don’t think of their illusions, they became selfish and with a main objective: kill each other to survive. Golding does not portray this loss of innocence as something that is done to the children; rather, it results naturally from their increasing openness to the innate evil and savagery that has always existed within them. http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/flies/themes.html
The best way to become the leader of the island is to have a symbol, something that portrays the image of the power and makes the rest of the people respect him/her. In this case, the possession of the conch shell reflect the control of everything without any objection. William Golding uses the figure of the conch to relate to the political democratic system. The white conch shell, being symbolic of the state of civilization on the island, helps to display the beginning of a mini-civilization, the slow deterioration of the this civilization, and finally the extinction of all civilization on the island. http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/469378/the_symbolism_of_a_conch_shell_in_lord.html?cat=38
As it was said before, the laws couldn’t be applied over a group of children because obviusly, they want to have fun and play with the other children. They finished refusing the help of the authority (Ralph and Jack) and everything finishes being a tremendous chaos that anyone could control, even Politics.
Civilization vs. Savagery
From the beginning of the book, it is clear that the character of Ralph represents the civilized part of the island and Jack the savage one. Their priorities became a problem when they meet each other and everyone is looking for a determinate objective. William Golding sets out to show what can happen when good meets evil, or in this case the Civilized versus the Savage. http://www.megaessays.com/viewpaper/85745.html
The negative consequences that the savagery provokes is the endorsment of the civilization and the destruction of all the human values. Being savage causes violence on the individuals and makes them act with their innate knowledges. The conflict between the two instincts is the driving force of the novel, explored through the dissolution of the young English boys’ civilized, moral, disciplined behavior as they accustom themselves to a wild, brutal, barbaric life in the jungle (…)
Lord of the Flies is a novel that reflects Golding’s main ideas from the children’s point of view and what he really wants to show is the fact that a society would become completely disordered and immeasurable if each individual or citizen of a particular society uses the savage as her/his first principle. Golding suggests that while savagery is perhaps an inescapable fact of human existence, civilization can mitigate its full expression. http://www.gradesaver.com/lord-of-the-flies/study-guide/major-themes/ As the novel is going on, it is relevant to take into account that the effects of the instincts of savagery and civilization causes in the children, each one in different degrees. At the end of the story, the island became an uncontrolled thing that even the human wisdom couldn’t escape from. The savagery beats the civilization in the moment which Piggy dies and the situation became intenable. By the final scene, savagery has completely displaced civilization as the prevailing system on the island. (…)
Introduction
In this essay, I am going to analyse all these aspects in more detail later on with this criticism based on the political system that in this case is represented by the figure of children in Lord of the Flies.
The hierarchical system established in this island becomes the form of government that children have to face. We could see throughout the play how below the leaders there are some hierarchies, those who are inferior and superior to Jack and Ralph. The main aspects that characterize children’s behaviour are the civilization and the savagery that they express with their innate actions. One of the solutions that children, and also humans, try to find is to have a leader, an authority which provides us with the necessary protection. These two aspects are the portrayal of a society governed by a democratic system and that’s what William Golding criticizes here: how would be our society without a powerful authority that controls the rest of the individuals.
27 octubre 2010
Conclusion
As I have told before, this play shows us how women are simply the object that men need to feel superior all the time. Women are the proof that men follow being the leaders in the English society in which Shakespeare had lived and, despite being conscious about their position, men keep on humiliating in a certain way every women’s aspect. Furthermore, they must remain silent due to the negative consequences that could be applied to them if they don’t respect the law and the established rules by the authority mainly composed of men.
Thus, it is shown in this play how women were married more with their duties as a housewives than with her husband. Little by little we could see how the progress in women’s lives are improving and in Midsummer’s Night Dream is shown as an imaginary episode that is not completely real in society. Shakespeare shows the importance of being women in a society in which everybody, even the most powerful forces, is against them. In addition, they are victims of a social problem that they try to solve by defending their own rights in order to become an equal part of the society as well as men and the rest of citizens in Elizabethan times.